The Star Decision: Key Governance Lessons for Directors and Senior Executives

In ASIC v Bekier & Ors [2026] FCA 196, the Federal Court delivered one of the most closely watched corporate governance decisions in recent years. The case arose from regulatory proceedings brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) against several directors and senior executives of The Star Entertainment Group.

 

The decision provides important guidance on the responsibilities of senior executives and boards when managing regulatory risk, particularly in businesses operating in heavily regulated industries.

 

While the Court found that two senior executives had breached their statutory duties, it dismissed the case against the company’s non-executive directors. The judgment provides valuable insight into how courts assess the respective responsibilities of management and boards in modern corporate governance.

 

For directors, executives and organisations, the case offers several practical lessons about risk management, governance and the flow of information within companies.

 

Background to the Proceedings

ASIC commenced civil penalty proceedings in 2022 against a number of current and former directors and officers of The Star Entertainment Group.

 

The regulator alleged that the company’s leadership had failed to properly manage risks associated with junket operators who brought high-value overseas gamblers to the company’s casinos. Junket arrangements were commercially important for the business but also carried heightened risks of money laundering and criminal association.

 

The proceedings focused on conduct between approximately 2017 and 2019 and raised several key issues, including:

 

  1. Alleged deficiencies in the company’s anti-money laundering controls;
  2. Concerns identified in an internal report about the adequacy of those controls;
  3. The company’s dealings with a major junket operator, Suncity; and
  4. Communications with the company’s banker concerning the use of China UnionPay cards by casino patrons.

 

ASIC argued that the conduct of certain directors and executives demonstrated a failure to exercise the care and diligence required under section 180 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

 

The Federal Court’s Findings

After a lengthy trial, Justice Michael Lee reached different conclusions for executives and non-executive directors.

 

Executives found to have breached their duties

The Court determined that the company’s former Chief Executive Officer and its Chief Legal and Risk Officer failed to meet the standard of care expected of officers of a large listed company.

 

The Court found that:

 

  1. The former CEO did not adequately address concerns raised in a report identifying weaknesses in the company’s anti-money laundering processes; and
  2. The Chief Legal and Risk Officer failed to ensure that significant risks connected with the Suncity junket relationship were properly brought to the board’s attention.

 

The Court also accepted that misleading information had been provided to the company’s bank about certain payment arrangements involving China UnionPay cards.

 

Two other executives had previously admitted breaches of duty in related proceedings.

 

The Court will determine the appropriate penalties in a subsequent hearing.

 

Non-executive directors cleared

By contrast, the Court dismissed ASIC’s claims against seven non-executive directors, including the former chairman.

 

Justice Lee concluded that ASIC had not established that the directors had failed to exercise the level of care expected of reasonable directors in their position. The evidence indicated that the board relied on information provided by management and was not fully informed of certain compliance risks.

 

The Court emphasised that directors are entitled to rely on information supplied by management unless there are clear warning signs that the information may be incomplete or unreliable.

 

Practical Lessons for Directors and Organisations

Although the case concerned the casino industry, the governance lessons extend to organisations across all sectors.

 

1. Senior executives must actively manage known risks

One of the central themes in the judgment is that executives cannot simply assume that significant compliance risks will resolve themselves. Where credible concerns arise, particularly those involving regulatory exposure, senior management must ensure that those risks are investigated, addressed and documented.

 

A failure to take meaningful steps in response to known risks can expose executives to personal liability.

 

2. Boards depend heavily on the quality of management reporting

Directors can only make informed decisions if they receive accurate and complete information from management. If material issues are not properly escalated, boards may be deprived of the opportunity to respond appropriately. In large organisations, this makes robust internal reporting systems essential.

 

Companies should ensure that risk reporting frameworks clearly identify when matters must be escalated to senior management and the board.

 

3. Governance failures often begin with breakdowns in communication

The case illustrates how serious governance issues can develop when information about risks is filtered or diluted before reaching the board. In practice, effective governance requires clear channels through which concerns can move quickly from operational teams to senior management and ultimately to directors.

 

Organisations should therefore regularly review whether their escalation processes operate effectively in practice.

 

4. The roles of management and the board remain distinct

The judgment reinforces an important governance principle: boards provide oversight and strategic direction, while management is responsible for running the business on a day-to-day basis. Directors are not expected to supervise every operational decision. However, they must remain sufficiently informed about key risks affecting the company.

 

When management reporting is incomplete or fails to highlight material issues, the board’s ability to perform its oversight role is significantly compromised.

 

5. Culture plays a significant role in governance outcomes

The case also demonstrates how organisational culture can influence risk management. If a culture develops in which difficult issues are downplayed or not escalated, governance frameworks may exist on paper but fail in practice.

 

Boards and senior executives should therefore focus not only on formal compliance structures but also on ensuring that employees feel able to raise concerns without hesitation.

 

Key Takeaways

The Star decision highlights an important reality of modern corporate governance: legal responsibility often turns on how organisations identify, communicate and respond to risk.

 

For directors and senior executives, the message is clear. Effective governance requires:

 

  1. Early recognition of compliance and regulatory risks;
  2. Transparent reporting of those risks to decision-makers;
  3. Active oversight by the board; and
  4. A culture that encourages escalation rather than silence.

 

Where these elements fail, the consequences can include regulatory action, reputational damage and personal liability for those involved.